Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Bubble burst or shakeout?

Once again, no shortage of drama in the markets as of late. I highlighted how I was seeing plenty of red flags back in September. Simply put, there was too much complacency at the same time cracks were showing up in market internals. The market topped out shorty after with the NASDAQ down 12% off its high and the SPX down about 6% off its high. 

In case you've been living under a rock, the main reasons for the latest rout in the market, tech in particular, started with Trump getting his ass handed to him in the midterms. There were also cracks in neo cloud space, Coreweave in particular, with credit spreads rising. The "blue wave" the US now has supposedly threatens the AI boom as more scrutiny will be imposed on AI companies and data center construction. Then, adding fuel to the fire was the scandalous news of Jensen Huang, arguably the most important person in the AI boom. This 1, 2 combo is pretty serious no doubt but it does not impact earnings at this point. Yes, the market's are forward looking and if becomes clear that future earnings will indeed be materially lower, the decline in AI related names will be justified and will likely continue. But, as it stands now, the blue wave and Jensen news present potential threats of material earnings decline, not a  near certainty of it and I'm sure many of the bearishly inclined would disagree with this, but until we actually see evidence of future earnings declining significantly (not just moderately) from current expectations the decline we've seen could end up being just a shakeout. Tonight is probably the most anticipated earnings release by NVDA of all time, not so much for Q3 numbers but more so for future guidance. Will they provide any hints that they will change their culture in regards to their support for the AI ecosystem? That's the question everyone is looking for to be answered. There is clearly a concern of succession risk in NVDA...that the new NVDA CEO will rein in the deals they have been making. 

Now let's talk indicators. The excesses I noted in my previous post have already been purged to a significant degree. As usual, not all the indicators are giving the same message but there's plenty of charts which show were seeing a significant sentiment reset with the market not even down 10% from the high. 








One of my favorite sentiment indicators is the equity allocation held by AAII investors. I have noted in my previous post how it hit red line territory. Coming into November equity allocation dropped notably by 1.7% but was still at an elevated 70% exposure.  It's quite likely that this allocation has dropped since then....the figure is released on the first day of the month and so we have to wait until Dec 1. 

I realize the bearish narratives about the AI space going bust are no joke. They are indeed serious. It also doesn't help that the Fed is poised to hike rates again in December, but let's look at the above charts from a "just woke up from a 5 year coma" point of view which I often do in order to filter out emotions and pre-dispositions. I would conclude as follows: we are close to at the very least, a ST low. There is also the possibility of this being the first leg down of a bear market similar to early 2022. We got a ST low in March of that year which ultimately led to a much lower low by June.  Such a similar scenario is quite possible here whereby we get a ST low soon which leads to a rally that ultimately fails. Whether that becomes a bear market or simply a severe correction like in late 2018 remains to be seen. As I've mentioned, the threats are serious. There is indeed justification for concern. It also doesn't help that Anthropic is going to go public Thursday...the timing is terrible for added equity supply to hit the market in a space that is already under severe pressure.  

Here's the thing that makes me think there's a decent chance that the "bubble" has not burst just yet. Its because we did not see the type of "nothing but blue skies" euphoria near the peak. Yes, there was froth but there was still an ample amount of underlying skepticism which had people one foot out the door. There was still no shortage of people calling AI a bubble or concerns about Trump and the economy. Now, look at the rush out of tech from hedge funds at the firs hint of weakness...its historic. In my previous post I mentioned the likelihood of a 10-20% correction. I will not be dogmatic about this...it could end up being less or more. If indeed the AI "bubble" did burst, then look at what happened back in March of 2000 after the tech burst. The NASDAQ dropped by 35% initially and then staged a final bear market rally of about 30% before the big damage happened. This is typical of bear markets....you get an initial decline followed by a bear market rally which retraces a significant amount of this initial decline. The same happened in 2022 - initial decline started in Jan, bottomed in March leading to one last good chance to get out. I have to consider this as a potential possibility here. How do we know if a rally off a low is "real" or a bear market rally? It's the way the rally behaves. In both cases you will get a strong initial surge from the low, but in a true bull market rally the subsequent advance after the initial surge will be a slow, low vol grind higher with short but punctuated pullbacks whereas with a bear market rally it will be more erratic and volatile. 

Something else to note...if the current trend in fuel prices can be sustained for a while, it could lower the  expectations for the Fed to hike rates at some point. Something I don't see many people talking about is how the 5 year breakeven inflation spread is currently at 2.25%. Finally, I will end by saying that this current decline gives me a nauseating feeling whereby I don't want to look at what the market is doing,..take that for what its worth every other time I mentioned I had this same feeling. 



No comments:

Post a Comment